Drop Shadows


Drop shadows are an easily overlooked design technique that can enhance the map by separating certain features such as legends and focal polygons visually from the rest of the map layout.

Map readers may not be immediately cognizant of the drop shadow but it helps their understanding and appreciation for the map just the same. As map makers, we need to be aware of this subtle yet powerful graphic element. We’ll start with some examples of drop shadows on existing maps and map layouts and then proceed to a few notes on how to apply a drop shadow in ArcMap and Illustrator.


From “New Plants on the Way?”, a map accompanying a 2006 article in the New York Times, Slow Start for Nuclear Reactors.
This is a classic drop shadow applied to the United States to separate it from the rest of the infographic.




From “Getting to the Tidal Basin Blossoms”, a map accompanying a 2005 article in the Washington Post, Cherry Blossom Guide.
This drop shadow provides a clear 3D height difference between the land and water.




A portion of the Marymoor Park map by Matt Stevenson, CORE GIS LLC.
Notice the drop shadows underneath the leader lines. They provide an important figure-ground differentiation.




A portion of the Seafloor Map of Hawaii map by Tom Patterson, who maintains shadedrelief.com.
The extremely subtle drop shadow to the bottom and right of the legend adds to the finished look of this exquisite map.

Tools

ARCGIS To create drop shadows in ArcMap, you must have ArcEditor or ArcInfo, and your data needs to be converted to a geodatabase. Use the representation > symbology tab. A tutorial on creating drop shadows this way is available on the ArcGIS resources site. If you only have the ArcView version of ArcMap, you can create a simple rectangular drop shadow for a simple rectangular legend by creating a rectangle graphic and offsetting it from the legend graphic. You can also create a rudimentary drop shadow by converting an irregular polygon feature to a graphic and then symbolizing that graphic via a gradient. Warning: at least in prior versions of Arc (I haven’t tried this in 10), gradient symbology was resource intensive and took a long time to render. Additionally, you can play with concentric buffers whereby each one is slightly lighter in color and more transparent than the last.

ILLUSTRATOR Select an object or an entire layer, then go to effect>stylize>drop shadow and click ok.

  1. #1 by LeighH on October 30, 2012 - 12:27 pm

    There’s also the “poor man’s drop shadow” – place a dark grey copy behind the layer or object, and then nudge it down and right. This is easy to do in Illustrator with the ‘Paste Behind’ command.

  2. #2 by Fran├žois Goulet on October 30, 2012 - 12:29 pm

    Great post!

    Wow, the ArcGIS tutorial is 10 pages long (ok, with pictures). Compared with the 3 clicks in Illustrator, it’s not worth doing it in Arc… No wonder I never bothered with it…

  3. #3 by Gretchen on October 30, 2012 - 1:29 pm

    Leigh and François…thanks for your input!

Comments are closed.